A MEA CULPA PERSPECTIVE ON HINDSIGHT
Of the many aphorisms on hindsight, the one which ought to be the truest was penned by the ancient Greek writer Homer: “After the event, even a fool is wise.” Too often and albeit for different reasons, policy makers and journalists have an ability to be the exception. One of the most sinister examples is jihadism and I was, in a small way, part of it.
Shortly after Islam’s mandatory midday prayers on October 27, 1983, in a dingy building in Baalbek, eastern Lebanon, a humourless man with a neatly trimmed beard and dark, fathomless eyes pulled a Beretta automatic pistol from under his jacket, placed it on the messy desk between us, and asked me what I wanted to talk to him about.
Four days earlier, at 6:22 a.m., a grinning bearded man in a Mercedes truck sped through two U.S. Marine guard posts at Beirut airport and into a four-storied building known as the BLT (short for Battalion Landing Team) and set off what FBI forensic investigators later determined was the single-largest non-nuclear explosion on earth since World War II. The blast killed two hundred and twenty Marines and twenty-one other American service personnel. It left a crater thirty feet deep. At the exact same time, another suicide truck bomber crashed into a building used by French paratroopers, killing fifty-eight.
A previously unknown group calling itself “Islamic Jihad” claimed responsibility.
My responsibility was to ask Hussein Moussawi, the man in front of me, whether he was, as the Reagan administration had publicly charged, the mastermind of the massacres.
A SORT OF EXCUSE
In hindsight, the place and circumstances encapsulated the hubris, fanaticism, willful ignorance, cultural chasms and pure evil that have woven the fabric of violence which bedevils modern times. At the time, my head was too busy trying to wrap itself around the problem of interviewing someone whose mindset was half a millennium removed from mine, with the power to inflict, with impunity, things too dreadful to contemplate on me and my camera crew, the legendary “Greeks”, Paul Vittoroulis and Georges Ioannides.
Added to that, the 9,000-year-old Phoenician city of Baalbek was infested with drug lords, Syrian military and Mukhabarat (secret police), Islamic Amal forces, Iranian Revolutionary Guards, and fifty members of the Red Army Faction terrorist group, all of whom were hyped up in expectation of American retaliation.
IN SIMPLE TERMS
Moussawi touted the Beirut bombings as a “natural consequence” of the presence of foreign troops on Lebanese soil. Americans, he said, did not understand that Moslems were willing to die for their cause.
“We are not afraid of Americans,” he snapped. “We will even confront their tanks with our daggers.”
Moussawi was boldly — and equally importantly, with pride – avowing the state of war that already existed between his ilk and the West, the U.S. in particular. Barely six months earlier, sixty-three people, among them seventeen Americans, were killed when a suicide bomber in a white van shattered the U.S. embassy in West Beirut.
On available evidence neither the Reagan administration nor the U.S. military grasped the significance. When the Marines were hit, their rules of engagement included: “When on post, mobile or foot patrol, keep loaded magazine in weapon, bolt closed, weapon on safe, no round in the chamber.”
THE LEGACY
While not on a par with the hubris that power-pointed the George W. Bush administration’s wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, it did imply a shocking unfamiliarity with a seminal quote from what many senior military officers I’ve met claim is essential reading for their profession, “The Art of War”, attributed to the Chinese military strategist Sun Tzu fifteen hundred years ago:
“If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle.”
The jihadists knew their enemy and quickly learned how to turn their cause into a franchise. ISIS grew out of the disastrous U.S. “de-Baathification” and army dissolution policy imposed on post-invasion Iraq.
The “caliphate” may have been destroyed, but its spin-offs add to Afghanistan’s misery, plague much of the impoverished but mineral-rich Sahel region and are gaining footholds in West Africa.
The metastasizing couldn’t have been extrapolated from Moussawi’s warning, but an abundance of studies has shown it deserved more attention than it got, both from the media and the policy planners, who still haven’t come up with a viable counter to the jihadists tried and tested business model.
Extensive interviews with (former) jihadists and defectors”… suggest that, in jihadist groups’ training camps across the continent, ensuring the recruits’ religious training and ideological compliance commands more effort and time than military trainings (sic).”
Homer may have been wise, but we’ve not always proved him right.
Comments are welcomed. Click CONTACT on the site header.
To receive e‑mail alerts to new posts, Click SIGN-UP on the header.
3 thoughts on “A MEA CULPA PERSPECTIVE ON HINDSIGHT”
Bonnie Haynes here. My late husband, Gen Fred Haynes And I also covered this for CBS from NY and DC. You are too kind to PX
Kelley and Reagan. Advance intel was on Kelleys desk.
Great piece. Does the best job of explaining the complicated and misjudged scenario. I a piece on domestic terrorism shortly after.
People laughed.
An incisive piece, Pizzers. Much to chew on. Within a year of your B’kaa session the Israelis were on their way out of ( most of ) Lebanon, the strategic Kidnappings had started, Western forces had scuttled and the nascent Hezbollah and allies ( your B’kaa interlocutor ) were with Syria taking back control. This is the response to the US/ West European military ‘edge’ given Israel. No good guys , as Randal used to insist to me, just ‘a forest of monsters’ ( Zuheir Mohsen).
History has proven Randall right, that’s for sure.