IT’S TIME TO HIT PAUSE AND REFRESH
The mid-term elections having defied predictions and avoided catastrophe, it would be a wise decision for the U.S. and a welcome relief for the rest of the world, if Americans heed an observation from one of their most trenchant homespun philosophers, Mark Twain: “The right word may be effective, but no word was ever as effective as a rightly timed pause.”
Part of that includes refraining from posturing as the leader of the free world and a beacon for democracy. The U.S. is indeed exceptional as a democracy, but not necessarily in all the ways its people perceive.
In an interconnected world beset by Covid, the effects of the war in Ukraine, climate change and ongoing refugee crises, other nations don’t have the time, never mind inclination, to sit back and wait for the U.S. to solve its domestic issues, let alone step up to help, guide or intervene in the way it used to do.
Does anyone really need direction from a nation where Donald Trump and his acolytes are a major preoccupation of the body politic?
YOU VOTED FOR THAT?
Evidence of how badly the self-created mantle of American exceptionalism has been tarnished, is provided by that most American of ways, opinion polls. An AP VoteCast survey of more than 94,000 participants in the midterm elections, found that two thirds of Republicans supported Trump’s “Make America Great Again” movement.
Another poll found 54 percent of Republicans had a very favourable opinion of him.
And how on earth did Herschel Walker, who cannot string a coherent sentence, never mind thought together, with a documented past of moral turpitude that is the antithesis of his party’s policy (abortion), end up winning enough votes to force a run-off? Especially against a man with the record and credentials of Rev Raphael Warnock.
The only nations where people believe they must vote for a party regardless of whether they find its policies, politicians and rhetoric acceptable or not, are dictatorships, where there is no choice.
To willingly endorse abhorrent ideas, malpractice, obfuscation, hate-preaching and a stated position that “if my side doesn’t win the election was rigged”, purely on the basis of not voting for anyone else no matter what, risks putting American democracy on the same level as that espoused by two of Trump’s most fervent foreign admirers, the autocratically-bent President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey and Prime Minister Viktor Orban of Hungary.
A LITTLE LESS WOULD BE MORE
Lest I seem partisan, let it be noted that obsession works both ways.The following headlines appeared as columns and Op-Eds (now pretentiously renamed “Guest Essay”), on the same day and page of an edition of the NY Times online:
“The Trump Show Is Back. Let’s Not Tune In.” (Excellent advice)/“Donald Trump Is Finally Finished” (Hopefully, but a tad premature)/“Trump’s Announcement Is a Sign of Weakness” (Maybe, but then, hubris is an American political constant)/“The Chaos Inside Donald Trump’s Mind” (Does anyone really want to go there?)/“The Big Liar and His Losing Little Liars” (The best column of them all)/“Why Trump Could Win Again” (Sadly, not necessarily a crazy premise.)
All of them were, to one degree or another, worthy efforts. But when even FOX News and the New York Post are giving His Trumpness short-shrift, is it not time for the mainstream media to afford a “rightly timed pause” and leave him to the late-night comics, for whom MAGA world is the gift that keeps on giving? (And yes, I know I just contributed to what I derided.)
TONE DOWN THE ENTITLEMENT
A pause in the whining about how much American motorists have to “pay at the pumps” every time the oil producers choose to gouge us, wouldn’t go amiss either. Europeans, among others, have been paying more for gas than Americans for years and will do so in perpetuity. The idea that Americans have a right to consume fossil fuels without any level of sacrifice is as perplexing as the concept of a God-given right to carry semi-automatic weapons in public.
Ditto American politicians, who had the temerity, or maybe that’s perfidy, to bring their domestic politics to COP 27, in the form of congressional Republicans railing against “radical environmentalism”.
Harjeet Singh, head of global political strategy for Climate Action Network International, reacted this way: “The U.S. has no sympathy, has no empathy. People are dying, and they don’t even want a system here to help them.”
Considering that President Joe Biden vowed Washington would both hit its climate commitments and share its progress with the rest of the world, that’s a little harsh.
However, it’s worth noting that seen from afar, the American ideal of the right to the “pursuit of happiness” tends to supersede consideration of the effects “the American way” has on the rest of the world.
It might also be a moment for “a rightly timed pause” to contemplate the wisdom of the philosopher Immanuel Kant: “Happiness is not an ideal of reason, but of imagination”.
Comments are welcomed. Click CONTACT on the site header.
To receive e‑mail alerts to new posts, Click SIGN-UP on the header.
7 thoughts on “IT’S TIME TO HIT PAUSE AND REFRESH”
With apologies to all sensible Americans but a country that would democratically elect Donald Trump as President, is not a country to be admired.
Especially in the U.S., in the age of a 24/7 news cycle and social media platforms a pause is just a void that has to be filled immediately by anyone with fast thumbs or a news outlet producer with a few seconds to fill. Pauses in speech, in reporting, or reacting could be considered thoughtful consideration or reflection, but more likely an assumed shadow of doubt. You can be the first voice of praise (Awesome!) or outrage (“You lie”), if you’re at the ready. To hell with correct spelling, a well crafted sentence, our calm voice, free speech is everyone’s right — the louder the better. A kind of example, yesterday a CTV reporter gave her first on camera report about the FIFA World Cup from Qatar. She mispronounced the country’s name a half dozen times. No one whispered in her ear “it’s not “Cah-tar” or suggested she do another take.. No time to pause. No time for questioning yourself. If the window is now opened, even a crack, jump in. “He (or she/them who hesitates…).
I fear/lament that the position, never mind concept of editing has gone the way of grammar in news reporting, which is to say to hell in a hand basket
This one is especially on target. Living in Munich for 10 years provided a different view of my country and how arrogant we are at times when dealing with other nations. I find it interesting that in a country whose politics are as corrupt as ours and which struggles to treat minorities fairly the State Department still issues an annual report judging other nations. Maybe a pause here too.
There’s a lot to admire about the U.S., but an awareness of “people who live in glass houses” certainly wouldn’t go amiss.
This is truly excellent. The sense of American exceptionalism existed as long as our frontier provided space to move and opportunity for people to improve their lives. We pretended to have escaped the class system and persecution we fled in Europe and elsewhere. Unless you were enslaved. But now we have become a fearful, squabbling people. We physically and mentally crowd each other, distrust each other. We are a damaged people dominated by acrimony. We brought it upon ourselves. While we still are a creative people and many continue to thrive, we have stained the American brand. We are not a happy people. Time for some basic introspection. Time for simple humility.
And I was concerned that as a non-American I might be seen as a bit harsh. Guess not.