THE SHREDDING OF MANDELA’S IDEAL
“I have cherished the ideal of a democratic and free society in which all persons live together in harmony and with equal opportunities.”
Nelson Mandela’s words on the day he was released from being the 20th century’s most famous political prisoner have been shredded by his successors.
The violence and looting that wracked South Africa in recent weeks ostensibly began as spontaneous protests over the jailing of disgraced former President Jacob Zuma.
His successor, Cyril Ramaphosa, called it a pretext “to provoke a popular insurrection” against the state. In fact, the riots were an orchestrated technique the South African police routinely used against anti-apartheid forces.
In 1986, black vigilantes known as witdoeke, Afrikaans slang for the white head covering they wore, attacked Crossroads squatter camp outside Cape Town to drive out supporters of the anti-apartheid United Democratic Front (UDF). Hundreds of shanties were burned.
Freelance cameraman George D’Ath was hacked and stabbed to death. Patrick Durand, a French photographer, was shot in the arm. Years later, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission reported that the witdoeke acted “with the tacit approval and aid of the security forces.”
It was widely believed at the time that the witdoeke’s motive was economic; a promise from the White authorities that if they drove out the UDF squatters, they could squat in their place.
POVERTY WEAPONISED
Much of the looting in the pro-Zuma ‘uprising’ was opportunistic — a natural consequence of grinding poverty and economic inequality. Unemployment has hit 33 percent, the highest rate in South African history. Nearly two thirds of under-35s are jobless. Electricity blackouts are routine. None of that should be the norm in a country with vast resources, including gold, diamonds, titanium and uranium.
South Africa was initially flouted as an exception to the mismanagement and corruption that plague much of the rest of the continent. That was before Jacob Zuma and his cohorts turned the upper echelons of the African National Congress party (ANC) into a kleptocracy clique.
By the time 25,000 troops managed to restore a measure of calm, forty thousand businesses, including stores, banks, factories and post offices had been vandalized or burned. Damage to the economy runs into billions of dollars.
‘Wrecking the joint’ for short-term gain only makes economic sense when your ambitions are limited by merely trying to get through the day. In a recent survey 65 percent of people said they struggle to put food on the table. When upward mobility is a chimera, ideals count for little.
WHEN YOU GOT NOTHIN’…
On a wet, dull day outside Durban in 1985, I watched a man struggling to carry a sheet of corrugated tin roofing. It was among the last salvageable things in the ruins of what had been the Phoenix Center, established by Mahatma Gandhi in 1904.
Intended as a multiracial experiment in non-violence, the unassuming settlement was where he coined the slogan: “Refuse to believe that you are weak, and you will be strong.”
It was destroyed in clashes between warring anti-apartheid factions. Teargas canisters, rubber bullets and discarded books were Gandhi’s final legacy.
The World Bank reported in March that South Africa is among the world’s most unequal countries, and inequality has worsened since the formal end of apartheid. As Bob Dylan put it: “When you got nothin’/You got nothin’ to lose.”
Whether that can be fixed will depend very much on whether Ramaphosa can root out the corruption and inefficiency that have gnawed into the heart of the ANC, the party which has ruled South Africa with an unassailable majority since it swept to power in the country’s first-ever majority-rule election 27 years ago.
Ramaphosa’s best hope is that the spirit and lessons of Madiba (Mandela’s tribal name) still have a hold. Barbara Holtman, a South African friend for more than 40 years standing, summed it up to me in an e‑mail:
“The riots ended a few days before Mandela Day, a time when South Africans are urged to do 67 minutes of community service in honour of Madiba’s 67 years of activism. This year there was an extraordinary response to the call; people came together to clean the looted sites, remove the trash, provide food parcels, support those who had lost so much. It’s not enough to change the world, but it’s a good start. In a country that suffers deep inter-generational trauma, this July has added a new layer.”
Maybe a “new” ANC should adopt a thought from the great artist Vincent van Gogh as its new slogan: “Great things are not done by impulse, but by a series of small things brought together.”
Comments are welcome, just click CONTACT
To receive alerts of future posts, click SUBSCRIBE
10 thoughts on “THE SHREDDING OF MANDELA’S IDEAL”
Excellent post. Thoughtful, reflective and spot on. Miss you coming to work here. In a 24 hr period we had hasmat suits then flak jacket / helmet all just a few kilometres from “home”. Last time we wore the two in combination was ebola DRC — only this time Adolph our Goma fixer was calling us in SA worried.
Thanks. Can’t say as the hazmat suits and flak jacket are my preferences any more, but I do sometimes miss Arfica, both South and the rest. Stay safe.
Excellent post. Thoughtful, reflective and spot on. Miss you coming to work here. In a 24 hr period we had hasmat suits then flak jacket / helmet all just a few kilometres from “home”. Last time we wore the two in combination was ebola DRC — only this time Adolph our Goma fixer was calling us in SA worried.
i recall the words of mr. mandela…he repeated them in his first post-release television interview
with cbs’ dan rather…i was fortunate to be present…
the problem with the ideals Mr. mandela cherished was the great expectation built
around the immediate dreams of homeownership and
equal financial opportunity…the American
ambassador, bill swing, told me the hill was steep and perhaps unattainable for quite some
years…the ambassador who became a good friend(saved my butt when he was posted to
haiti) thought the rise from apartheid’s depths
to a booming and equitable democratic nation wasn’t a glide but a slog…
“it takes a very long time to unwrap the tentacles
of ineptness and corruption that have strangled
South Africa”(allen’s figures on the RSA economy)…
the unwrapping continues, glacially, but it
does continue and the people of South Africa
will be rewarded…some day…
For all the awful tragedies of the apartheid regime and the appalling treatment of the foreign press that you received first hand .. the debilitating corruption of Zuma and even after the recent opportunistic rioting, you remain a fair and positive voice.
It gives me hope for South Africa.
Having said that .. I’ve just watched the news this Saturday 32st 😩
Brings back a flood of memories, including the day the day I was covering the High Court in Johannesburg when the government kicked you out of the country.
and then they had to let me back in again..sweet revenge
Together with every thing which seems to be developing inside this subject material, your opinions are very radical. On the other hand, I am sorry, because I do not subscribe to your whole theory, all be it stimulating none the less. It appears to everyone that your remarks are actually not totally validated and in reality you are your self not even completely certain of the assertion. In any case I did enjoy reading it.
Thanks for reading, and taking the time to comment. I don’t think of myself as “radical”, but I appreciate your point of view.